Credit Card vs. ACH Payments for Gym Memberships
By Kurt of Gulf Management Systems, the RhinoFit Preferred Payments Processor
Editorial update: November 12, 2026. The RhinoFit team updated the payment-cost and settlement discussion below. This article was originally published in 2017.
No matter how diverse or different one business is from another, we all have one thing in common: we must collect payments for our services. Some businesses are fortunate enough to have clients pay in cash, but most must collect payments with a client’s credit card or bank account.
There are significant benefits from pulling money directly from a client’s account, such as having a recurring stream of income and ensuring the payments come in on time. However, these benefits come at a tangible cost; the bill from your merchant service providers.
No Difference Between Cash & Electronic Payments
Consider for a moment that in the abstract, there is no difference from a client paying cash or collecting the payment over an electronic medium. Both methods are conveying a set amount of currency from your client’s possession into your possession. However, the mechanical process to move the money has a value, and so does the client’s experience in paying their bills.
As a client, it is easier to have your money come from your account when it’s due, as opposed to having to go to an ATM to get cash and bring it in. Likewise, it is easier for a business to have automated systems collecting their membership fees instead of having to physically collect cash, log the cash to user accounts, and then deposit the cash. Therefore, the distinction between these methods is in the convenience to the business and their client, and this convenience comes at a cost.
Compare the Full Cost of Gym Membership Payments
Payment costs depend on your merchant agreement, payment method and transaction amount. Compare the written pricing for each option, including any per-transaction, monthly, return or chargeback fees that apply. A percentage rate or flat transaction fee alone does not describe the full cost of collecting membership dues.
Credit cards and ACH can have different pricing structures. Ask your processor to review your typical membership amounts and payment volume, and confirm the charges that apply to your account. Avoid assuming that every ACH payment has a flat fee or that one payment method is always the cheapest.
ACH Settlement and Merchant Funding
The U.S. ACH Network supports same-day and next-banking-day settlement; ACH credits can also be scheduled for two banking days. Nacha explains that ACH debits settle on the same or next banking day. See Nacha’s explanation of how ACH payments work.
Network settlement is separate from the payout schedule your processor provides to your business. Confirm the services available on your account, submission cutoffs, funding schedule and handling of returns before promising members or staff a particular timing. For Canadian bank-payment options, confirm the applicable service and timing with your provider; this ACH explanation describes the U.S. network.
Choose Payment Options That Fit Your Gym
Consider your members’ preferences, your billing workflow, applicable costs and the funding schedule your business needs. Ask your payment provider to explain the available card and bank-payment options before changing how you collect dues.
For information about payment processing options inside RhinoFit, call Gulf Management Systems at 800-947-3156 or explore RhinoFit gym payment software.